Getting caught in a criminal case doesn’t always mean you were the one directly committing the crime. Sometimes, being in the wrong place at the wrong time—or helping someone else in a way that contributes to their crime—can land you in serious legal trouble. If you’ve been accused of aiding or helping a criminal, understanding Indiana’s laws on accomplice liability is critical. 

This blog will walk you through what it means to be an accomplice under Indiana law, examples of actions that could lead to such charges, potential penalties, and defenses you might use. The goal? To help you grasp your rights and options if you’re facing accomplice charges. 

What Is Accomplice Liability in Indiana?

Under Indiana criminal law, accomplice liability refers to holding someone legally accountable for a crime they knowingly helped another person commit. Importantly, you don’t have to physically commit the crime yourself to be charged as an accomplice. Assisting, encouraging, or even planning an offense with someone else can make you just as culpable under the law. 

Accomplice liability often comes into play in cases involving charges like aiding a crime, conspiracy to commit a crime, or maintaining a place of a common nuisance. These charges are serious and carry penalties similar to those for the person who directly committed the offense. 

Indiana’s Legal Definition of an Accomplice 

Indiana law broadly defines an “accomplice” as someone who knowingly—or intentionally—helps or encourages another person to commit a crime. This includes both physical actions (e.g., providing tools or transportation) and verbal encouragement (e.g., persuading someone to break the law). 

The key element here is your intent. You can only be charged as an accomplice if the prosecution proves that you knowingly assisted the offender with the specific intent to enable the criminal activity. Accidental or unknowing assistance generally does not qualify. 

Legal Standards for Accomplice Liability in Indiana 

To convict someone of being an accomplice, Indiana prosecutors must prove several elements beyond a reasonable doubt. These include: 

1. You knowingly acted to aide, abet, or encourage the commission of a crime. 
2. You participated voluntarily—there wasn’t coercion or force involved. 
3. Your actions were tied directly to the criminal offense.  

It’s worth noting that all accomplices involved in a crime are treated equally under Indiana law. This means if you act as an accomplice to aiding and abetting a bank robbery, the penalties you face could mirror those of the primary offender. 

Actions That Could Lead to Accomplice Charges 

Not sure what counts as “helping a criminal”? Here are several examples of actions that could land someone in legal trouble as an accomplice in Indiana: 

Providing Assistance 

• Supplying tools, weapons, or resources used in the crime. 
• Giving someone a ride to or from the scene of the offense. 

Encouraging Criminal Activity 

• Convincing, pressuring, or persuading someone to commit a crime. 
• Offering financial support to carry out illegal activities. 

Concealing the Crime 

• Helping the perpetrator hide evidence or dispose of stolen goods. 
• Lying to authorities to provide an alibi for the offender. 

If these actions sound broad, that’s because the law intentionally casts a wide net to discourage aiding or involving yourself in criminal activity. 

Penalties for Accomplice Liability in Indiana 

The penalties for acting as an accomplice depend on the severity of the underlying crime. Indiana law categorizes offenses into misdemeanors and felonies, with varying penalties that can include jail time, fines, or probation. 

• Misdemeanor Accomplice Charges: For lower-level crimes—like vandalism or petty theft—you could face penalties including up to 1 year in jail and fines of up to $5,000. 
• Felony Accomplice Charges: Felony charges carry much harsher consequences. For instance, aiding and abetting a Class A felony—such as armed robbery—can lead to decades in prison and steep fines. 

Regardless of the charges, being labeled as an accomplice can have long-term effects on your reputation, finances, and freedom, which is why it’s essential to take these allegations seriously. 

Defenses Against Accomplice Liability 

Fortunately, several legal defenses can help you fight accomplice liability charges in Indiana. Here are a few common strategies your attorney might employ on your behalf: 

Lack of Knowledge 

You can’t be convicted as an accomplice if you were unaware that your actions would contribute to a crime. For instance, if someone used your property without your knowledge to commit an offense, you may not be held liable. 

Lack of Intent 

If prosecutors cannot prove you acted with the intent to help or encourage criminal activity, their case may weaken. Having a strong attorney to challenge the evidence is crucial here. 

Withdrawal from the Crime 

If you initially agreed to participate but later withdrew and made efforts to prevent the crime, this could serve as a defense. For example, calling law enforcement or trying to stop the offender could show you didn’t support the illegal act. 

Coercion or Duress 

If someone forced you to aid their crime under threat or harm, you might use coercion as a defense. This acknowledges that your actions weren’t voluntary and thus shouldn’t merit punishment. 

Similar Offenses that Can Land You in Cuffs

Visiting or Maintaining a Place of Common Nuisance

This charge applies when someone regularly visits or maintains a location known to be used for illegal activities. If you are aware of ongoing criminal activity at a specific place and continue to visit or support it, you could face this charge as an accomplice. 

Promoting Professional Gambling

This offense involves aiding in the operation of gambling—like organizing games or handling money—for profit. As with other crimes, if you knowingly participate in promoting professional gambling, you may face charges as an accomplice. 

Conspiracy to Commit a Crime

When two or more individuals agree to carry out an illegal act, they may be charged with conspiracy. As an accomplice, you could face charges if you intentionally help plan or execute the crime, even if it never comes to fruition. 

Final Thoughts

Accomplice liability is a complex area of Indiana criminal law that underscores the importance of understanding how your actions—or even your words—can have serious legal consequences. While you don’t have to directly commit a crime to be held accountable, the law does require proof of knowing and intentional assistance for a conviction. By being aware of the actions that may qualify as aiding or abetting, you can better safeguard yourself from legal trouble.

If you are facing allegations of accomplice liability, consulting with an experienced criminal defense attorney can be crucial to protecting your rights and building a strong defense. Remember, being proactive and informed is your best first step in navigating these serious legal challenges. Every second counts when your future is on the line. Get the legal assistance you need now! 

If you—or someone you know—are being charged as an accomplice to a crime in Indiana, don’t wait to seek legal representation. Contact Attorney David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 for the strongest criminal defense in Indianapolis. We will get the best possible outcome for your criminal case!

Related Posts:

Innocent Until Proven Guilty: Strategies for a Strong Criminal Defense
4 Ways Prank Calling Can Get You Arrested in Indiana
Facing Harassment Charges in Indiana? What Every Defendant Should Know