A conviction can feel final and overwhelming, but Indiana’s appellate courts offer a lifeline to those seeking justice. Whether due to an error during the trial, ineffective legal representation, or the improper admission or exclusion of evidence, you may have valid grounds to appeal. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about appealing a conviction in Indiana, from identifying grounds for an appeal to understanding the appeals process. 

What is an Appeal? 

Before we begin, let’s define an appeal. An appeal is a formal process where a higher court reviews the decision of a lower court to determine if legal errors occurred during the trial. Unlike a trial, an appeal doesn’t involve new evidence or witnesses; instead, it focuses on identifying and addressing errors in the application of the law. 

Grounds for Appeal 

To successfully appeal a conviction, you must demonstrate that significant legal errors affected the outcome of the trial. Here are the most common grounds for appeal in Indiana: 

Ineffective Counsel 

Under Strickland v. Washington, legal representation must meet a standard of reasonable competence. If your attorney’s performance fell below this standard and negatively impacted your case, it could be grounds for appeal. For example, failure to call key witnesses, inadequate cross-examination, or neglecting critical evidence may constitute ineffective counsel. 

Evidentiary Errors 

The improper admission or exclusion of evidence during a trial can unfairly affect the verdict. The Indiana Supreme Court case Evans v. State highlighted how errors made in the handling of evidence, such as wrongful interpretation of the rules of admissibility, can warrant an appeal. 

Procedural Issues 

Mistakes in jury instructions, such as those addressed in Washington v. State, can skew a fair trial. Similarly, prosecutorial misconduct, as explored in Timberlake v. State, is when prosecutors act improperly, such as by withholding exculpatory evidence or making prejudicial remarks to a jury. 

Lack of Sufficient Evidence 

If the evidence presented at trial was insufficient to sustain a guilty verdict, the conviction may be appealed. Judges in Indiana appellate courts assess whether any rational jury could have found the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. 

The Appeals Process in Indiana 

Here’s a step-by-step breakdown of the appeals process in Indiana so that you know what to expect: 

1. Notice of Appeal

Start by filing a Notice of Appeal with the trial court clerk. This document informs the court and opposing parties of your intention to appeal. According to Indiana Rule of Appellate Procedure 9(A), this must be done within 30 days of the judgment. 

2. Preparation of the Record

Once the notice is filed, trial records, transcripts, and other relevant documents must be prepared and submitted to the appellate court. 

3. Submission of Briefs

Your appellate lawyer will draft a brief outlining the legal errors that occurred during the trial and present arguments for overturning the conviction. The other party, referred to as the appellee, will file a response brief. 

4. Oral Arguments

In some cases, parties may be called to make oral arguments before the appellate court. This is an opportunity for the lawyers to clarify their points and answer judges’ questions. 

5. Appellate Court Decision

After reviewing the briefs and hearing oral arguments, the appellate court will issue its decision. 

Appeal Filing Deadlines

Meeting strict deadlines is absolutely crucial for a successful appeal. Missing key filing deadlines, such as the 30-day window to file a Notice of Appeal in many jurisdictions, can result in your case being dismissed outright, leaving you with no further legal recourse. Appeals are highly procedural, and every step must be carefully followed to stay within the court’s timeline.

Your appellate lawyer will ensure all necessary documents are prepared, reviewed, and submitted on time, avoiding costly errors that could jeopardize your case. This is why hiring experienced appellate counsel is not just important—it’s essential for protecting your legal rights and giving your case the best possible chance of success.

Contact Us for a Free Case Evaluation

Potential Outcomes 

An appeal can result in several outcomes, depending on the circumstances and grounds presented. Below are the most common possibilities: 

• Conviction Upheld – The appellate court may determine that no significant errors occurred during the trial, which means the conviction stands. 
• Reversal – If the court finds errors significant enough, it may reverse the conviction entirely. 
• Remand for a New Trial – The court might order a new trial, giving you the opportunity to present your case again. 
• Modified Sentence – Sometimes, an appeal can lead to a reduced sentence or changes in penalties. 

The Importance of Seeking Experienced Legal Help 

Appealing a conviction is a complex and technical process that requires legal expertise. An experienced Indiana criminal defense attorney, familiar with local laws and precedents, can be the difference between success and failure. For example, they’ll know how to leverage cases like Strickland v. Washington or Timberlake v. State to strengthen your case. At the same time, they’ll ensure all deadlines, procedures, and document submissions are handled meticulously. 

If you or a loved one is facing an unjust conviction, don’t wait to seek guidance. Consulting with a qualified appellate lawyer can provide clarity on your options, improve your chances of overturning the conviction, and give you the support needed to move forward. 

Take the Next Step Toward Justice 

An appeal can be your second chance at justice, but it requires thorough preparation and expert guidance. Whether your concern is faulty evidence, legal representation, or procedural errors, now is the time to explore your options. 

If you believe your conviction merits further review, contact Attorney David E. Lewis today for a consultation. We’ll assess your case, guide you through the appeals process, and fight for the justice you deserve. 

Click Here to Call Our Office Directly

Related Post: Indiana Criminal Appeals: What You Need to Know