How to Determine if You Need to Hire a Criminal Attorney or Not

Posted on May 21, 2021 by admin

Were you just arrested for an offense in Indiana, but you are not sure whether to hire or lawyer or not for your case? Are you thinking about opting for a public defender instead of hiring a private criminal attorney? If you aren’t sure if your criminal charges warrant the investment of a private lawyer, you are lucky to be in the right place at the right time. Regardless of how major or minor your recent criminal charges are, it is always recommended to hire a criminal defense lawyer to represent your case.

Continue below to learn why, and how to get started on building a strong and impactful defense against your Indiana criminal charges soon.

Indianapolis IN Criminal Defense Law Firm 317-636-7514

Private Criminal Defense is Always the Best Option

The types of crimes a person can be charged with is seemingly endless, ranging from minor infractions like traffic tickets and citations, to major crimes like capital offenses. The penalties for these crimes vary in nature as well, and depend on a long list of factors. And the consequences for committing a crime can range from a minor fine to the death sentence.

But regardless of the scope and severity of a defendant’s charges, it is important to take them very seriously. Not only can a guilty plea hand down various penalties, but it can also spoil a person’s reputation and have life-long adverse effects on the quality of their life. For this reason and more, it is vital to hire an experienced criminal attorney if you are currently facing criminal charges. They have the knowledge and resources to build a strong and impactful defense to protect your rights and preserve your freedoms. They can help you pursue the best possible outcome to your case.

What a Criminal Attorney Will Do for You

Even for minor offenses, like traffic tickets, a criminal attorney can help you avoid the maximum fines and penalties associated with your infraction. They might even be able to fight the allegations and dismiss your case, such as a speeding ticket, or even prevent your drivers’ license from being suspended. They know how to find the facts and properly investigate allegations in order to fight your criminal charges. Reducing minor infractions is always wise because it can also protect you against increase insurance rates and more.

If your criminal charges are more serious, it is even more critical to your freedom and your future to retain professional legal counsel. Private legal counselors, unlike public defenders, have the time and the resources to dive into your case and put in the effort and focus it needs to have a successful outcome.

With private criminal defense, you are in better hands than none at all. It can mean the difference between extended jail time and no jail time. It can also increase the chances of reducing Level 6 Felonies to Class A or B misdemeanors. It all depends on who you choose to represent your case. Experience and testimonials are the greatest indications of quality and trust.

Were you convicted of misdemeanor or felony weapons crime? Contact Attorney David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 for the best chance at reducing or dismissing your Indianapolis IN criminal charges. Consults are free!

You Might Also Read:

4 Reasons to Fire Your Lawyer and Hire a New One
Should I Waive My Right to a Lawyer if I Know I’ll Be Found Guilty?
What Can a Criminal Lawyer Do That a Public Defender Can’t?

Indianapolis Criminal Defense 317-636-7514 — Schedule a Free Consultation Today!

Why Private Criminal Defense is Always the Best Choice

Posted on May 18, 2021 by admin

When faced with the decision of choosing between a free public defender and a paid private criminal defense attorney, it is important to not think about cost. Instead, you must think about the well-being of your rights, your freedoms, your future, and your family. Regardless of how minor your offense may be, choosing a public defender is incredibly risky and strongly discouraged.

Continue reading to learn why private criminal defense is always worth it, and how you can afford to hire a lawyer to fight your criminal charges.

A Public Defender Might Eventually Get to Your Case. Or They Might Not.

Always Choose Private Defense When Facing Criminal Charges

It is vital to entrust your rights and freedoms in an experienced criminal defense lawyer who has the time and resources to devote to your case. The good news is that criminal defense representation for minor infractions is more affordable than you think. Making the choice to hire private counsel over free public defense is worth the cost because you will get better results. Public defenders are overloaded with cases, and cannot devote the amount of time and focus to each individual case like a private counselor can.

No Case is Too Minor for a Criminal Defense Lawyer

Whether caught shoplifting a pack of gum or trespassing onto private property, there is no offense too petty or minor for a private attorney. Penalties like jail time, community service, fines, suspended drivers’ licenses, revoked professional licenses, and more, may all be on the docket of maximum penalties for your particular charges. So, if you want the best chance at avoiding maximum penalties for your pending criminal charges, you must make the best choice for your future and hire private representation.

Most Important Reasons to Choose Private Counsel:

Private lawyers have the time, knowledge, and experience to know whether or not certain evidence should be suppressed or challenged.

Private lawyers understand the workings of a complicated legal system and have the time to navigate any obstacles or complexities.

Private lawyers know when it is best to accept a plea bargain or settlement.

What to Take Away From This Blog

In conclusion, the money a person may save by going with a public defender can cost them much more in the long run. The tradeoff of saving money versus a comfortable life is not worth it at all. A private lawyer will be by your side through your entire legal journey, working as an advocate for your rights and your freedoms. This is an investment worth the cost.

Are you facing criminal charges in Indianapolis, but afraid you cannot afford an attorney? Contact the Law Office of David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 to schedule a free consultation with a seasoned Indianapolis Indiana criminal lawyer, today.

You Might Also Enjoy:

What Can a Criminal Lawyer Do That a Public Defender Can’t?
Answers to Your Questions About Public Defenders
Can I Request a New Public Defender?

Facts About Police Stops and Pat Downs

Posted on May 14, 2021 by admin

When a police officer decides to pat you down or frisk you, are they within their rights in all cases? Are they allowed to stop and frisk at their own discretion? Without any merit? Continue below to learn what you need to know about cop stops and pat downs, including how to defend your criminal charges if you were just arrested after a similar police encounter.

Illegal Search and Seizure Criminal Lawyer Indianapolis Indiana 317-636-7514

Detention and Search

What’s commonly referred to as a stop and frisk is also known as a detention and search. Because of the Supreme court decision handed down in the Terry versus Ohio (1968) case, they are also called Terry stops or Terry frisks. No matter the moniker, this type of police encounter occurs when a cop decides that a person might be committing, or has recently just committed a crime and asks them to stop and answer some questions. This is the detention part, which is not the same as being under arrest (Fourth Amendment). As for the search, police officers will pat a person down to check for illegal drugs, weapons, contraband, or paraphernalia.

Police Officers Must Have Probable Cause

Cops are not permitted under law to stop just anyone they want at any time for no reason at all. Police officers must have probable cause to stop and question a person. To arrest them, they must have probable cause or a warrant. Probable cause can mean a lot of things, including evidence, witness statements, and suspicious behavior. This means that cops can find probable cause at their own discretion.

So, although it might seem like a police officer stops someone for no reason, professional training and strategies used by law enforcement can allegedly spot the signs of suspicious or criminal behaviors. Upon being stopped by a police officer for reasons of suspicion, you can expect a pat down to follow, as this is normal procedure to check for threats or weapons.

If a cop detains a person without reasonable cause, the arrest and charges would be inadmissible in court.

Am I Free to Go or Not?

If a person is stopped by police for questioning, whether or not they are free to leave depends on the cop’s behavior and communication. If a cop is touching you, has their weapon out, or using a harsh tone of voice, then you are NOT free to leave. In these situations, you are being detained by police and cannot leave at your own discretion.

Confused? Don’t be. Typically, you will just feel it; you will know that you are or are not allowed to stop the conversation and walk away from a cop who is questioning you. If you ask the cop if you are free to leave and they answer yes, then you can end the discourse and walk away without repercussion.

Are you facing Indiana criminal charges after being stopped by a cop on the street? Contact the Law Office of David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 for aggressive Indianapolis Indiana criminal defense you can afford.

You Might Also Like:

Examples of Unlawful Search and Seizures
Do I Have to Consent to a K9 Sniff Search?
Is it Illegal to Insult a Cop?

Should I Hire a Lawyer to Expunge My Criminal Records?

Posted on May 11, 2021 by admin

Because the criminal record expungement process is so complex and requires a concentrated approach, it is necessary to hire a criminal defense lawyer to navigate your petition if you want successful results. Continue below to learn some important facts about Indiana criminal record expungement and sealing that will help you better understand the importance of retaining professional legal assistance and teach you how to get started.

Criminal Expungement Lawyer Indianapolis Indiana 317-636-7514

Criminal Record Expungement Law

Indiana’s Second Chance law (IC §35-38-9) was enacted on July 11, 2013. It permits the permanent sealing of a criminal record from public access or view. Although the general public cannot access or view an expunged criminal record, some parties can, such as the government and law enforcement officials. Those who cannot include current employers, potential employers, landlords, banks, college admissions offices, credit card companies, dating partners, coworkers, family, friends, and similar types of private, non-governmental parties.

Expungement Process

There are various stages of the criminal record expungement process, all of which your skilled defense lawyer will navigate for you. But here is a basic breakdown:

☑ Gather all necessary documents and evidence needed for the petition.

☑ Complete the expungement petition and submit it by the required deadline.

☑ Continue to file all remaining documents and copies with the proper county clerks’ office.

☑ Satisfy all filing fees. You may choose to fill out and submit a fee waiver that would excuse you from paying any filing fees.

☑ Receive a case number and court date.

☑ Attend the hearing and complete the argument for expungement.

Criminal Record Expungement Costs

How much does it cost to expunge or seal criminal records in Indiana? Well, it all depends on the lawyer you choose, their personal fees, and the complexity of your case. Lawyer fees generally start at $1,000 or so, and then you might also have to pay filing fees and related costs. There is no fee to submit the actual expungement petition, however.

Why You Need a Lawyer to Help With Your Expungement Paperwork

The process that is required of the petitioner for record sealing or expunging is highly complicated, and revolves around a stringent schedule that’s difficult to follow. One little filing mistake or missed deadline, and a person loses their chance at sealing their public criminal history forever. For these reasons, it is imperative to retain the professional legal counsel of a licensed attorney that’s familiar with the Indiana expungement laws and provides services for filing and petitions.

Are you looking for a qualified criminal defense lawyer who can help you with your petition? Contact the Law Office of David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 to schedule a free consultation and get your Indianapolis Indiana criminal record expungement appeal started.

You Should Also Read:

Criminal Record Expungement FAQS for 2021
Can I Expunge My Arrest if I Am on Probation?
Who Can Access Expunged Criminal Records?

What to Do if You are Facing Felony Assault Charges in Indiana

Posted on April 29, 2021 by admin

If you are facing felony assault and/or battery charges in Indiana, there is no time to waste. You must get started on your defense as soon as possible if you want a chance at avoiding the maximum penalties, including jail time. Continue reading to learn what to do and how to protect yourself after being arrested or indicted on felony assault charges in Indiana.

Indianapolis IN Assault and Battery Lawyers 317-636-7514

What is Assault and Battery?

The crime of Assault and battery is considered a violent criminality in our state. “Assault” denotes the threat of violence, whereas “battery” refers to “offensive, angry, or insolent” physical contact. Both are highly reprimanded crimes in Indiana, and those convicted could face serious life-long consequences.

Assault and Battery Charges in Indiana

If you are currently dealing with assault and battery charges, time is not on your side. It is crucial to take immediate action and hire professional legal counsel since the side of prosecution is already building their case against you. For this reason and many more, it is vital to hire an Indianapolis criminal defense law firm as soon as possible to protect your rights and preserve your freedoms. Because such charges are so serious, and come with a harsher level of penalties, it is necessary to invest in private criminal defense. It is not wise to take a public defender if you are facing a felony conviction.

Who to Trust for Indiana Criminal Defense for Assault Charges

David E. Lewis, Attorney at Law, is the tough and aggressive assault and battery attorney you need to protect your future and get you the fairest possible outcome for your case. You can trust him to defend your rights and guide you through the Indiana criminal process, all while keeping your personal best interests in mind. His years of experience and heightened knowledge of criminal law will be your primary defense weapon against over-penalization and jail time.

Ready to get your defense started? Contact the Law Office of David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 and schedule a free case evaluation to discuss possible defenses for your felony crimes assault and battery charges in Indiana.

You Should Also Read:

Possible Court-Ordered Penalties for Felonies and Misdemeanors in Indiana
Information About State Felony Appeals and Criminal Defense
How Can I Get a Job if I Have a Felony?

Indiana Laws Regarding Knives and Blades

Posted on April 22, 2021 by admin

Whether you’re a hunter, Boy Scout, fisherman, or simply a weapon enthusiast, it is important for you to understand the laws surrounding knife ownership, concealment, and possession here in Indiana. Regardless of our Second Amendment rights, one can still be in violation of these laws, even without knowing it.

Continue reading to review the top Indiana laws regarding knives and blades, and who to call if you were recently charged with the knife offense.

Indianapolis Indiana Criminal Defense 317-636-7514

Knife Laws in Indiana

There are various laws that regulate the ownership and possession of knives and blades in Indiana. Everything from how long the blade is allowed to be to where you’re allowed to carry it, and everything in between, knife laws are very serious in our state. If you are caught in violation of any knife laws, you could face certain penalties, such as fines and repossessions, or perhaps even criminal charges if the offense is particularly serious. Some knife violations are actually felony offenses, which can lead to jail time and much more.

Here are the knife facts you need to know in Indiana:

Switch Blades

A switchblade knife is a knife that has a button on the handle, and when you push it, the knife opens up with the spring action. Here in Indiana, switchblade used to be legal, until 2013 when they were allowed to be sold and possessed once again.

Knife Concealment and Length

Although some states have laws regulating how long blades are allowed to be an laws that require concealment when carrying a knife, Indiana does not have any laws like this. You are not legally required to conceal your knife when carrying it in public, nor are you limited to how long you want your blade. Many knife enthusiasts here in Indiana alone machetes, swords, and similar collectible pieces, and it’s perfectly legal.

Concealment Exceptions in Indiana

Although you don’t have to have your knife concealed or partially concealed when clipped to your belt or pants, there are some exceptions to this leniency. You are not allowed to carry or reveal a knife on school property, school buses, nor in airports, courthouses, or any of the places where it states that it’s strictly prohibited. Under Indiana Code 35-47-5-2.5, violating these laws would be a Class B misdemeanor.

Reckless Behavior and Violent Crimes

Here in Indiana, use of an edged weapon of any kind in a way that is violent, aggressive, or threatening is illegal and a felony.

Detachable Blades

Knives with detachable blades also have strict regulations. According to Indiana Code 35-47-5-2, you cannot display, possess, manufacture, or sell knives with detachable blades. The charge for this offense would be a Class B misdemeanor.

Chinese Throwing Stars

Chinese throwing stars are illegal in Indiana. You cannot own, sell, or manufacture Chinese throwing stars in our state, nor any weapon with blades placed at different angles. The penalty is a Class C misdemeanor. Indiana Code 35-47-5-12

Were you convicted of misdemeanor or felony weapons crime? Contact Attorney David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 for superior Indianapolis IN criminal defense that will reduce or dismiss your criminal charges, and avoid jail time. We offer free initial consultations.

You Should Read:

Brief Explanation of Indiana Gun Laws
Can a Cop Be Fired For Inappropriately Using a Non-Lethal Weapon?
Are You Innocent of a Recent Criminal Charge in Indiana?

What are My Constitutional Rights After Being Arrested?

Posted on April 19, 2021 by admin

Whether guilty or innocent, your constitutional rights should be your top priority after experiencing an arrest. This applies whether you are physically arrested on the spot or have just received notice of an arrest warrant. Continue reading to learn exactly what your constitutional rights are during the criminal justice process, and how to find skilled and aggressive criminal defense in Indiana.

Constitutional Rights and Amendments

Of the 27 amendments in the United States Constitution, there are 5 particular ones that protect the basic rights of criminals. These rights are offered to all U.S. citizens, and cannot be denied under any circumstances. They include the 4^th Amendment, 5^th Amendment, 6^th Amendment, 8^th Amendment, and 14^th Amendment.

The 4th Amendment

This amendment provides protection to citizens in the case of arrests, searches, and seizures. It prevents law enforcement from implementing unlawful searches and seizures of property, as well as decrees the limitations and requirements for search warrants.

The 5th Amendment

The 5th amendment is particularly important for those suspected of a crime. It mandates that all citizens due process of law, as well as prohibits a person from being tried twice for the same crime, also known as “double jeopardy.” It also protects defendants from being forced to provide testimony against themselves: “nor shall [any person] be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself.” This is often referred to as “pleading the fifth.”

The 6th Amendment

This amendment involves your rights to a “speedy and public” trial. It also provides your rights to an attorney and a trial by an impartial jury. This includes being informed of your charges and the evidence against you, and being permitted to be present when witnesses are testifying against you. It also allows you to call witnesses to your defense.

8th Amendment

The 8th Amendment gives citizens protection against excessive bail. This means that bail must be set at a reasonable and consistent rate, and match the type of crime. “(…) Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.”

14th Amendment

The 14th Amendment specifically acknowledges how the law must abide by these rights when prosecuting a suspected criminal. Furthermore, it guarantees all citizens equal protection of the law, regardless of age, class, status, income, race, religion, or ethnicity. “…nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law, nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”

Do you want to avoid the maximum penalties and jail time for your current or pending criminal charges? Contact the Law Office of David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 to schedule a free consultation with a seasoned Indianapolis Indiana criminal lawyer who will build you a strong and impactful defense.

You Should Also Read:

What are My Rights at Trial?
Which U.S. Amendments Protect Criminals’ Rights?
Understanding Your Miranda Rights

Does Your Indiana Criminal Defense Case Involve Aggravating Factors?

Posted on April 14, 2021 by admin

What are aggravating factors? If you were recently arrested in Indiana, and your criminal charges involve aggravating factors, you need to read this. Continue below to learn what you want to know about your aggravating factors, including what they mean, how they can impact your ultimate judgement, and how you can build a strong and impactful defense against them.

Indianapolis Indiana Criminal Defense Lawyers 317-636-7514

Aggravating Factors

Aggravating factors are specific facts and elements involved in your alleged offense that can make your criminal charge more serious. Ultimately, if the judge or jury finds that your criminal charges do in fact involve aggravating factors, your sentence and subsequent penalties will be harsher than if your case did not involve aggravating factors. Here’s an example: Jeff was arrested for selling drugs. The location in which he was caught by law enforcement trafficking illegal drugs was within 50 yards of an elementary school. Because his offense took place within close proximity to the school, this element would be considered an aggravating factor.

In another example, if a person were to commit the crime of assault and battery against a person, Indiana statutes would penalize them with a Class B misdemeanor. However, if their offense caused the opposing party bodily harm, it would be considered an aggravating factor to the case, and their criminal charges would be increased to a Class A misdemeanor. In the same example, if the offender used a weapon against the victim, such as a baseball bat or even a beer bottle, it would be considered another aggravating factor, so the criminal charges would be increased to a Class C felony.

Mitigating Factors

Do not confuse aggravating factors with mitigating factors. Mitigating factors, also known as extenuating circumstances, are the opposite of aggravating factors because instead of increasing the severity of the charge, they reduce it or suggest the opportunity for leniency. For example, if a person is arrested shoplifting at a store to satisfy a substance abuse addiction, their criminal charges might be reduced if they agree to alternative forms of sentencing such as drug rehabilitation. This element would be considered a mitigating factor to their case.

Are you facing aggravating factors in your current or pending criminal case? Contact the Law Office of David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 to schedule a free consultation with a seasoned Indianapolis Indiana criminal defense lawyer who cares about your freedoms.

You Might Also Enjoy:

The Difference Between Aggravating and Mitigating Factors
Factors That Affect Jail Sentences
How Your Sentence Will Be Determined as a Defendant Facing Criminal Charges

Read This if You Were Arrested But Not Convicted in Indiana

Posted on April 9, 2021 by admin

Quickly answer these questions:

⇛ Have you ever been arrested in Indiana?
⇛ Were you not convicted after your arrest?

If you answered yes to both of these questions, you will be thrilled to hear that you are likely eligible to have that arrest record expunged from your criminal history. Continue reading to learn more about Indiana criminal record expungement, and how to get started on your petition today.

An Arrest Doesn’t Have to Be a Part of Your Past Anymore.

Get to Know Indiana Criminal Record Expungement

Criminal Record Expungement in Indiana

Also known as the Second Chance Law, Indiana criminal record expungement legislation now allows past offenders, even many of those who do have convictions, to destroy or seal their arrest records from the general public. What does this mean for you? Well, those who clean up their criminal record have better quality lives because they are more eligible and qualified for job opportunities, promotions, professional licensing, international traveling, education opportunities, rental and housing opportunities, and so much more. In fact, you’d be surprised to learn just how much a criminal record can hold person back from having a better quality of life.

So how you get started on criminal record expungement in Indiana?

You first have to hire a criminal defense lawyer who is well-versed in the Indiana second chance Law and all subsequent legislation changes and modifications. Not only is the law complex, but the application process for criminal record expungement or record sealing is very complex. Furthermore, even one small error, such as a misspelled word or a missed deadline, will eliminate you from being eligible for expungement because you applicants can only petition once. A second petition won’t even be glanced at.

Arrested But Never Convicted?

If you are arrested under suspicion of committing a crime, but the arrest never led to a conviction, you are in a good position to apply for criminal record expungement in Indiana. Usually, these types of cases are granted much faster than those with convictions. Even if your conviction was vacated, or you had an order of protection placed against you, you are still eligible for Indiana’s Second Chance Law. The only catch: you have to wait one year from the date of your arrest. For many, the arrests they wish to eliminate from their criminal record happened years ago; if this is like you, you are already eligible to get started on your petition.

Are you interested in learning more about your criminal record expungement eligibility? Contact the Law Office of David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 to schedule a free consultation, today. We specialize in criminal record expungement legal assistance, and our services start as low as $850!

You Might Also Like:

Criminal Record Expungement FAQS for 2021
Can I Expunge My Arrest if I Am on Probation?
Indiana Will Now Let You Expunge Protection Orders

What You Need to Know About Receiving a Notice of Deposition

Posted on April 7, 2021 by admin

Did you just receive a notice of deposition in the mail, and you have no idea what it means or what you should do next? If so, you are just like millions of other deponents who have stood where you are standing now. There is no shame in being confused or scared about your obligation to fulfill your deposition duties. By preparing yourself ahead of time, which involves understanding what to expect and how to cooperate, you can ease the anxiety you might feel about being a testifier in a criminal court case, plus ensure a successful experience.

Continue below to learn what you need to know about receiving a Notice of Deposition, and where to find trusted criminal lawyer advice in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Indianapolis Criminal Trial Lawyer 317-636-7514

Why Did You Get a Notice of Deposition?

There are a few different reasons why courts use Notices of Depositions. The most likely reasons why you have received one is because the courts want to know what you know, and/or preserve your testimony for use later on, either for the actual trial or when motions are filed with the court. The authority who sent you the Notice of Deposition wants your official testimony because they think it will help prove their case. Even if you are not a party to the case, the Indiana Rules of Trial Procedure makes it legal for the parties involved to call upon the testimony of any person within 20 days of the commencement of the case.

How to Prepare for Being Deposed

You will be asked a series of questions, and expect to answer them clearly and in detail. So, prepare mentally for this interrogation-like setting. To best prepare, you should hire a defense lawyer to help you understand what to expect and how to behave during your deposition. Furthermore, they can defend you in the case that you are wrongly targeted or cornered into doing something you are not comfortable doing.

Here are some additional tips for a successful deposition:

⚖ Be Entirely Honest. Prior to giving your testimony, you will be sworn in under oath. For this reason, you do not want to lie or embellish about anything, as you could be found guilty of perjury, which comes with a lengthy punishment sheet. Be truthful with your answers, and simply answer, “I am not sure” if you do not know the answer.

⚖ Take Your Time Answering. Do not just blurt out your answers off the top of your head. The written court transcript does not show time lapses between the question and the given answer, so you can take as much time as you need. Think carefully about your answer, and do not use “uh-huh’s” and short, one-word answers. Be throughout.

⚖ Only Answer the Given Question. You do not want to offer more information than what was asked of you. Do not volunteer extra information; only answer the question that was asked. Furthermore, only answer what you actually know. Do not try to fill-in pieces of information, no matter how arbitrary or unimportant it might seem to you. Be clear, honest, and precise with your answers.

Are you looking for a trusted criminal lawyer for help with your deposition or legal case? Contact David E. Lewis, Attorney at Law, at 317-636-7514 to schedule a free consultation with an aggressive Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer who can defend you against wrongful prosecution.

You Should Also Read:

The Importance of Witness Depositions in a Criminal Case
The Top Three Rules for Testifying in Court
Can a Child Be a Witness in a Criminal Case?