Tag Archives: traffic stops

The Importance of Cooperation During an Indiana Cop Stop

Posted on by

Seeing flashing lights in your rearview mirror can be a stressful experience. Your mind might race, and you may wonder what you did wrong. Police stops, whether for a routine traffic violation or a more serious investigation, are a part of law enforcement’s duty to maintain public safety. However, it’s just as important for you to understand your rights and how to navigate these encounters effectively.

This guide will explain the key aspects of police interactions in Indiana, from understanding the difference between being detained and arrested to knowing how to cooperate without giving up your rights. By learning how to handle a traffic stop, you can help ensure the situation is resolved as smoothly and quickly as possible.

Call 317-636-7514 if You are Looking for a Cop Stop Criminal Lawyer in Indianapolis
Call 317-636-7514 if You are Looking for a Cop Stop Criminal Lawyer in Indianapolis

Detainment vs. Arrest: What’s the Difference?

One of the most confusing parts of a police encounter is understanding your status. Are you being detained, or are you under arrest? The distinction is crucial, as it affects your rights and what you should do next.

Detainment

This is a temporary stop for investigation. An officer can detain you if they have “reasonable suspicion” that you have been, are currently, or are about to be involved in criminal activity. During detainment, you are not free to leave, but you are not under arrest. The stop should be brief and is meant to allow the officer to confirm or dispel their suspicion. For example, being pulled over for a traffic violation is a form of detainment.

Arrest

An arrest occurs when police have “probable cause” to believe you have committed a crime. This is a higher standard than reasonable suspicion. When you are arrested, you are taken into custody. An arrest is a more significant restriction of your freedom.

Knowing the difference helps you understand the situation. If you are unsure, you can politely ask, “Am I being detained, or am I free to leave?” If they say you are being detained, you can follow up with, “Am I under arrest?”

Your Rights During a Police Stop

During any police encounter in Indiana, you have fundamental rights protected by the U.S. and Indiana Constitutions. Understanding these rights is your first line of defense.

The Right to Remain Silent

You have the right to not answer questions about where you are going, where you are coming from, or what you are doing. You are legally required to provide your name, and if you are driving, your license, registration, and proof of insurance. Beyond that, you can politely state, “Officer, I am choosing to remain silent.” Many people mistakenly believe that staying silent makes them look guilty. This is false. Your silence cannot be used against you in court as evidence of guilt.

The Right to an Attorney

If you are arrested, you have the right to consult with a lawyer. You should clearly state, “I want to speak to an attorney.” Once you request a lawyer, the police must stop questioning you—they can only continue to question you if your attorney is present. You will still be booked and processed into the jail, but without being interrogated.

The Right to Refuse Searches Without Probable Cause

Police cannot search your vehicle or your person without your consent, a warrant, or probable cause. If an officer asks to search your property, you can say, “Officer, I do not consent to a search.” If they search anyway, do not physically resist, as this could lead to additional charges. An unlawful search can be challenged in court later by your criminal defense lawyer.

If the police officer has probable cause, they can legally search your vehicle. Be sure you understand probable cause laws. For example, if a cop thinks she detects an odor of burnt marijuana on your person or from inside the vehicle, that is enough “probable cause” for them to legally conduct a search of the vehicle and any belongings inside the vehicle (purse, cases, bags, etc.) without your consent.

Contact an Indianapolis Criminal Lawyer Today! ✨

Why Cooperating with Police Matters

While it’s crucial to assert your rights, cooperation can significantly influence the outcome of a police stop. Cooperation does not mean admitting guilt or giving up your rights. It means interacting respectfully and calmly, which can help de-escalate a tense situation.

A smooth, professional interaction may lead to a quicker resolution. An officer who perceives you as cooperative may be more inclined to issue a warning instead of a ticket for a minor traffic infraction. However, it’s a common misconception that cooperation guarantees a favorable outcome. Even if you are polite and helpful, you may still face charges. The key is to be cooperative in your demeanor while being firm in protecting your legal rights.

How to Cooperate Effectively

Here are some practical tips for interacting with police during a traffic stop:

  1. Pull Over Safely: As soon as you see the police lights, find a safe place to pull over. Turn on your interior light at night and keep your hands visible on the steering wheel.
  2. Stay Calm and Be Polite: Your tone of voice matters. Address the officer as “officer” and avoid arguing or becoming defensive.
  3. Provide Required Documents: Have your driver’s license, vehicle registration, and proof of insurance ready to hand over when requested.
  4. Remain Obedient to Even the Smallest Order: No matter how small or insignificant the request, obey every single order given by the officer, such as “stop looking in your purse”, “turn off the vehicle”, or “roll down your window more.”
  5. Know When to Stop Talking: Answer basic identification questions, but remember you can remain silent about anything else. Politely decline to answer questions about your activities. Anything you say can be used against you. Trying to talk your way out of a situation often provides officers with more information than they had initially.

How to Document the Encounter

In some situations, you may feel it’s necessary to document the stop. This can be helpful if you believe your rights were violated.

  • Inform the Officer: If you plan to record, calmly inform the officer that you are doing so. Indiana is a one-party consent state, meaning you can legally record your own conversations with police. Keep in mind, all police officers have body cameras that will record every bit of footage from your traffic stop, including before they pull you over.
  • Record Overtly: Do not try to hide your phone or recording device. Place it in a secure location on your dashboard or have a passenger record.
  • Focus on Audio: Clear audio is often more important than video. Capture the conversation between you and the officer.
  • Write Down Details: As soon as the encounter is over, write down everything you remember, including the officer’s name, badge number, the reason for the stop, and what was said.

When to Seek Legal Advice

While not every traffic stop requires a lawyer, there are times when contacting a criminal defense lawyer is essential. You should seek legal advice if:

  • You are arrested for any crime, including a DUI.
  • The police searched your vehicle or person without your consent.
  • You believe the stop was unlawful or your rights were violated.
  • You are issued a summons to appear in court.

An experienced Indiana criminal defense lawyer can review the details of your case, identify any violations of your rights, and build a strong defense on your behalf.

Your Next Steps After a Police Stop

Navigating an Indiana traffic stop can be intimidating, but knowing your rights empowers you. Remember to stay calm, be polite, and be firm in your rights. While cooperation can lead to a smoother interaction, it’s your right to remain silent and refuse unwarranted searches.

If you have been arrested or charged with a crime following a police encounter, don’t face it alone. Understanding the law is the first step, but having a skilled legal advocate is critical. Contact Attorney David E. Lewis for a free consultation to discuss your Indiana criminal charges and learn how we can protect your rights.

Book Your Case Review Now

Related Post: How to Keep Yourself Safe During a Cop Stop

Understanding Indiana’s Implied Consent Law: Your Rights and Responsibilities

Posted on by

Getting pulled over during a traffic stop can be overwhelming, especially when you’re facing potential DUI charges. Many Indiana drivers don’t fully understand their rights and obligations under the state’s Implied Consent Law until they find themselves in this challenging situation. This law significantly impacts what happens during a DUI stop and the choices you’ll need to make quickly.

Indiana’s Implied Consent Law creates automatic responsibilities for anyone who drives on the state’s roads. By simply operating a vehicle, you’ve already agreed to certain chemical testing procedures if an officer suspects impairment. However, the reality of this law is more complex than many people realize, with important nuances that can dramatically affect the outcome of your case.

Understanding these legal requirements isn’t just about knowing what might happen during a traffic stop—it’s about protecting your rights and making informed decisions when you’re under pressure. The consequences of your choices during a DUI stop can follow you for years, affecting your driving privileges, employment opportunities, and personal freedom.

Call 317-636-7514 if You are Looking for a DUI Lawyer Near Indianapolis
Call 317-636-7514 if You are Looking for a DUI Lawyer Near Indianapolis

What Does Implied Consent Mean Under Indiana Law?

Implied consent refers to the legal principle that by driving on Indiana’s roads, you automatically agree to submit to chemical testing if a law enforcement officer has reasonable suspicion that you’re operating under the influence. This consent is “implied” because you don’t explicitly state your agreement—it’s assumed through your act of driving.

Types of Chemical Testing

Under Indiana Code 9-30-6-2, this law applies to tests measuring blood alcohol concentration (BAC) or the presence of controlled substances in your system. The most common tests include breathalyzer testing, blood draws, and urine analysis. Importantly, this law covers all substances that could impair your driving ability, not just alcohol.

The Legal Basis

The legal foundation for implied consent rests on the idea that driving is a privilege, not a right. When the state grants you a driver’s license, part of that agreement includes submitting to these tests when legally requested. This framework has been upheld in numerous court cases, including State v. Gilbert, which detailed the procedural aspects of how officers must handle implied consent situations.

Misconceptions About Refusal 

Many drivers mistakenly believe they can simply refuse testing without consequences. While you do have the right to refuse, that choice comes with automatic penalties that are separate from any DUI charges you might face.

When Does Implied Consent Apply During Traffic Stops?

Reasonable Suspicion and Testing 

Implied consent doesn’t automatically apply to every traffic stop. An officer must have reasonable suspicion that you’re impaired before requesting chemical testing. This suspicion typically develops through observations like the smell of alcohol, slurred speech, bloodshot eyes, erratic driving behavior, and more.

The process usually begins with field observations during your initial interaction with the officer. If these observations suggest impairment, the officer may request field sobriety tests. It’s crucial to understand that field sobriety tests are voluntary and not covered under implied consent requirements. You can refuse these roadside tests without facing the automatic penalties associated with refusing chemical tests.

When Implied Consent is Activated 

However, if the officer decides to arrest you for DUI based on their observations, implied consent requirements become active. At this point, you’ll be asked to submit to chemical testing, typically at the police station or hospital. The case Johnson v. State clarified many aspects of what constitutes proper procedure during these stops and how officers must inform drivers of their rights.

The location of your traffic stop doesn’t exempt you from implied consent requirements. Whether you’re stopped on a public highway, in a parking lot, on private property where the public has access, or even in your own driveway, the law generally applies if you’re operating a motor vehicle.

Contact Us for DUI Defense in Indianapolis ☎

Consequences of Refusing Chemical Tests

Immediate Administrative Penalties 

Refusing to submit to chemical testing under Indiana’s Implied Consent Law triggers automatic administrative penalties through the Bureau of Motor Vehicles (BMV), separate from any criminal DUI charges. For a first-time refusal, your license will be instantly suspended for one year. If you have prior DUI convictions or refusals within the past five years, the suspension period extends to two years.

These administrative penalties occur regardless of whether you’re ultimately convicted of DUI charges. The refusal itself violates your implied consent agreement, and the BMV will act on this violation independently of criminal court proceedings. This means you could face license suspension even if criminal charges are later dropped or dismissed.

Refusal as Evidence in Court 

Additionally, your refusal to take chemical tests can be used as evidence against you in criminal court. Prosecutors often argue that refusal indicates consciousness of guilt—that you knew you were impaired and refused testing to avoid incriminating evidence.

However, there are some limitations on how refusal evidence can be used. Courts have established that prosecutors cannot suggest that refusal automatically proves guilt, but they can present it as one factor for the jury to consider alongside other evidence of impairment.

Legal Penalties and Long-term Consequences

DUI penalties in Indiana extend far beyond license suspension, creating long-lasting impacts on multiple aspects of your life. A first-time DUI conviction typically results in license suspension for 90 days to two years, depending on your BAC level and other factors. You’ll also face potential jail time ranging from 60 days to one year, along with fines up to $5,000.

Repeat offenses carry substantially harsher penalties. A second DUI conviction within five years can result in license suspension for up to two years and potential felony charges. The court may also require installation of an ignition interlock device, which prevents your vehicle from starting if alcohol is detected on your breath.

Extended Impact

Beyond immediate legal consequences, DUI charges create lasting effects on your employment opportunities, insurance rates, and personal reputation. Many employers conduct background checks that will reveal DUI convictions, potentially limiting job prospects. Insurance companies typically classify DUI convictions as high-risk behavior, leading to dramatically increased premiums or policy cancellation.

Professional licenses in fields like healthcare, education, or finance may also be affected by DUI convictions. State licensing boards often review criminal convictions and may impose additional penalties or restrictions on professional practice.

Exceptions and Potential Defenses

Medical Exceptions 

While implied consent creates broad testing requirements, certain exceptions and defenses may apply to your situation. Medical conditions that prevent safe blood draws or breathalyzer testing can sometimes provide grounds for challenging test results or refusal penalties. However, officers are typically required to offer alternative testing methods when medical issues arise.

The case Indiana v. Kimbrell addressed important issues surrounding blood draws and medical considerations in implied consent situations. This ruling established protocols for handling cases where medical circumstances complicate standard testing procedures.

Procedural Violations 

Procedural violations by law enforcement can also provide defense opportunities. Officers must follow specific protocols when informing drivers about implied consent requirements and conducting chemical tests. If proper procedures weren’t followed, it may be possible to challenge the validity of test results or the penalties for refusal.

Timing Issues 

Timing issues can also affect the validity of chemical tests. Indiana law requires that testing occur within a reasonable time after arrest, typically within three hours. Tests conducted outside this window may face challenges regarding their accuracy and legal admissibility.

Protecting Your Rights During a DUI Stop

Understanding your rights during a traffic stop empowers you to make informed decisions under pressure.

✏ You have the right to remain silent beyond providing basic identification information. Anything you say can be used as evidence, so limiting your statements to essential responses protects you from inadvertently providing incriminating information.

✏ While you must comply with requests for license, registration, and insurance information, you’re not required to answer questions about where you’ve been, whether you’ve been drinking, or how much you’ve consumed. Politely declining to answer these questions is within your rights and cannot be used against you.

✏ Remember that field sobriety tests are voluntary. Officers may not clearly explain this, but you can decline to perform roadside balance tests, eye tracking tests, or other field sobriety evaluations without triggering implied consent penalties. However, refusing these tests may still influence the officer’s decision to arrest you based on other observations.

If you’re arrested and face chemical testing requirements, the decision becomes more complex. While you can refuse, understanding the automatic consequences helps you make an informed choice based on your specific circumstances.

In Summary

Facing DUI charges creates immediate stress and uncertainty about your future. The complexity of implied consent law, combined with the serious consequences of these charges, makes professional legal guidance essential. An experienced DUI attorney can evaluate the specific circumstances of your case, identify potential defenses, and guide you through both administrative and criminal proceedings.

Your Next Steps

Time is critical in DUI cases. You typically have only ten days from your arrest to request a hearing with the BMV regarding license suspension. Missing this deadline can result in automatic suspension without the opportunity to challenge the administrative penalties. Consult with a qualified DUI attorney who understands Indiana law and can protect your interests throughout this challenging process.

Ready to defend your DUI charges and get the best possible outcome in court? Contact Attorney David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 for immediate criminal defense representation in central Indiana.

Schedule a Free Consultation Now

Related Post: Indiana Laws About Giving a Breath Sample During a DUI Stop

5 Types of Probable Cause for DUI Traffic Stops

Posted on by

Although the facts will differ among all cases of drunk driving arrests, there is a general guideline that police officers use to determine probable cause in a DUI traffic stop. Continue reading to learn what signs and clues law enforcement look for to establish probable cause in a drunk driving arrest and what to do if you were recently charged with a similar offense in Indiana.

DUI Lawyers Indianapolis IN 317-636-7514
DUI Lawyers Indianapolis IN 317-636-7514

Reasonable Suspicion for Traffic Stops

When it comes to DUI traffic stops, it is important to understand the difference between reasonable suspicion and probable cause. In all cases of traffic stops, whether a driver has been drinking alcohol or not, law enforcement must have reasonable suspicion that a driver has committed a traffic violation or infraction before pulling them over. Once pulled over, law enforcement must then establish probable cause to make an arrest.

In order for a police officer to legally arrest a person for a DUI, there must be probable cause, which is evidence that supports an officer’s reasonable belief that a driver is intoxicated, or under the influence of a drug or controlled substance.

Reasons You Might Have Been Pulled Over for Drunk Driving

Both reasonable suspicion and probable cause can be a means to a DUI arrest. Police officers can use either principal, or both, to conduct a legal traffic stop and establish an arrest. The types of probable cause or reasonable suspicions can vary depending on each situation of intoxicated driving. However, these are the top 5 reasons why police officers pull people over and arrest them for drunk driving:

❶ Traffic Violations

Traffic violations are one of the top reasons why people are pulled over, regardless of alcohol involvement. Common traffic violations include expired license plates, illegal U-turns, illegal parking, failure to use turn signals, ignoring traffic signs, running red lights or stop signs, and most recently, texting and driving.

❷ Reckless Driving

Poor driving is another common reason why police officers pull people over. If a person is exhibiting bad or reckless driving, a cop can legally pull them over to conduct a traffic stop. Examples of reckless or bad driving include speeding, following too closely, failing to yield, ignoring traffic signs, driving too slow, and similar risky behaviors.

❸ Car Accidents

Speaking of risky behaviors, law enforcement can use the occurrence of a car accident to establish reasonable suspicion to question a driver. Whether you are at fault for a car accident or not, police can question you, and if it comes down to it, arrest you for a DUI. They would need to make some observations to establish a legal basis for arresting you, though. See below to learn more.

❹ Mid-Stop Observations

Once a police officer has pulled a driver over, they can continue their investigation by keeping their eyes open for tells or signs that a person has been drinking alcohol or using illicit drugs. A cop can establish probable cause and make a DUI arrest if they smell alcohol on your breath, hear you admit to having a drink earlier, see alcohol containers in your car, catch you in a lie, and more. Other signs that officers use as evidence of drunk driving include slurred speech, glossy or red eyes, dilated pupils, slowed movements, incoordination, insubordination, crying, and hostility.

BAC Testing

To really seal the deal and come in with some valid evidence to support their reasonable suspicion and probable cause, law enforcement relies on field sobriety testing and blood-and-alcohol (BAC) testing. Also known as chemical testing, a breathalyzer is one of the most common devices used during traffic stops to determine a driver’s level of alcohol in their system, and therefore, reveal how much they’ve had to drink within a 24 hour time period.

The legal limit is 0.08 percent BAC. If you blow this or more, you will be arrested on DUI charges. Upon being arrested, and with your consent, law enforcement will request to have your blood drawn and tested to confirm a precise BAC value.

Field sobriety testing is another strategy used by law enforcement to establish probable cause for a DUI arrest. Walking the line, touching the nose, and following the pen with the eyes are typical phases of a field sobriety test.

Were you recently arrested for a DUI or similar offense in Indiana? Contact the Law Office of David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 for aggressive and skilled DUI criminal defense in Indianapolis, Indiana. Our teams work around the clock to reduce or dismiss your DUI penalties and avoid jail!

Related Posts:

What You Should Do if You are Pulled Over for a DUI
Top Myths About Breathalyzer Tests
What You Can and Can’t Legally Do When Stopped By a Cop

Indianapolis Criminal Defense 317-636-7514
Schedule a Free Consultation Today!

Use These 3 Tips to Avoid Being Pulled Over By a Cop

Posted on by

Nobody wants to be pulled over by the police, whether for a routine traffic stop or a drunk driving offense. To avoid being pulled over by police, there are some certain things you can do. Continue reading to learn the top three ways you can prevent yourself from being stopped by a cop, as well as what to do if you were recently pulled over and charged with an offense in Indiana.

Criminal Defense and Appeals Indianapolis IN 317-636-7514
Criminal Defense Lawyers Indianapolis IN 317-636-7514

Your Rights During a Police Stop

Law enforcement officers are not permitted under law to stop just anyone they want at any time for no reason at all. They must have probable cause to stop and question a person for purposes of determining whether or not a crime is being or was committed. Although law enforcement can stop a person and detain them without arrest, they cannot detain them for an unreasonable amount of time or indefinitely without making an arrest and filing charges.

This violates our constitutional right against unreasonable searches and seizures. To arrest them, they must have probable cause or a warrant. So, although it might seem like a police officer stops someone for no reason, professional training and strategies used by law enforcement can allegedly spot the signs of suspicious or criminal behaviors.

How to Be a Non-Target for Law Enforcement

As for pulling people over, law enforcement’s top priority is to ensure the safety of all drivers and passengers on the road. Mostly, they are looking for intoxicated drivers, drug traffickers, reckless speeders, and similar offenders. Whether you are doing something illegal or not, in order to avoid being arrested or cited for a traffic offense, follow these three important tips:

❶ Stick to Your Car’s Routine Maintenance Schedule

One of the most common reasons for being pulled over unexpectedly is for automotive defects like a dimmed taillight, broken turn signal, or some other type of illumination or equipment defect. In many cases, a minor traffic offense leads to additional officer suspicions, thus resulting in additional charges like DWI’s, drug possessions, suspended license, and more.

So, be sure to stay current on all scheduled car maintenance according to your car’s owners’ manual. This will prevent your vehicle from experiencing any sort of unanticipated equipment malfunctions or automotive defects that can lead police officers to pulling you over. For instance, if your head or taillights are not illuminated brightly enough, law enforcement will be inclined to pull you over insight you.

❷ Stay Compliant With All Local and State Regulations

It is also very common to be pulled over if your plates or driver’s license is expired, or if you have not renewed the license plate stickers. Furthermore, if the cop runs your plates and learns that your vehicle is not properly insured or registered, they will also pull you over. So, to avoid being pulled over for these minor infractions, it is wise to ensure that you are always in compliance with all local and state automotive regulations.

❸ Drive Mostly in the Daytime

If you restrict the majority of your driving during the daytime only, you can avoid being pulled over by police significantly. Not only can you see police officers better, but you can also see the roads better, which can reduce your chances of making any driving errors or traffic mistakes that bring attention to you.

Were you recently pulled over and arrested for a crime in Indiana? Contact Attorney David E. Lewis at 317-636-7514 for the best chance at reducing or dismissing your Indianapolis IN criminal charges. Our legal team specialize in DUI charges, drug possession crimes, drugged driving charges, and similar criminal traffic offenses. Consultations are free so act now and get started on your defense today!

You May Also Like:

Do I Need a Lawyer for Traffic Court?
Do Not Fall for These OWI Arrest Myths
Facts About Police Stops and Pat Downs

Indianapolis Criminal Defense 317-636-7514
Schedule a Free Consultation Today!